On January 19, 1967, the first New York revival of By Jupiter opened off-Broadway at the Theatre Four. Directed by Christopher Hewett with choreography and musical staging by Ellen Ray, the production starred Bob Dishy and featured Jackie Alloway and Sheila Sullivan. Featuring some new material by Fred Ebb, the production retained most of the original Rodgers & Hart score. The show closed on April 30, 1968, after 118 performances.

Reviews were generally positive. Richard Watts, Jr., of the New York Post called it “a thoroughgoing delight,” saying the show’s “melodiousness, humor, high spirits and charm, together with the skill and freshness of its presentation, made it one of the joys of the season.” James Davis of the Daily News concurred, calling the production “an appetizing dish indeed,” adding, “Everyone can take a bow for this one.”